Celebrating 10 Years of Allergy Free Mouse!

Earl of Sandwich with multiple food allergies – Downtown Disney

This quick review was provided by Maria P, who is allergic to Eggs, Peanuts, Tree Nuts, Soy Flour, and Soy Protein.

Dining at Earl of Sandwich with multiple food allergies in Downtown DisneyAs soon as we got there my husband got in line with the kids and I asked the first cast member I saw if I could speak to the manager about allergy safe choices. The manager came right out and went over the menu with me. Because we had the dining plan and our children with allergies are 3 and 4 we only had 3 items to discuss.

The children’s menu includes grilled cheese, pizza sandwich and turkey and cheese. The bread is all egg free there but the pizza sauce is the same as the sauce for the meatball sandwiches and the meatballs are cooked in peanut oil. The turkey and cheese sandwich is fine if you order it without mayonnaise.

By the time we reached the front of the line all 7 of us had figured out our order. The meals on the dining plan come with entrée, drink and dessert. All the desserts are made in-house and labeled with the ingredients. Unfortunately the ingredients list on some things were vague. The chocolate pudding listed ingredients as chocolate pudding, whipped cream and strawberry. Now Jell-O chocolate pudding is okay but I asked about theirs’ since it’s homemade. Good thing I asked, it had egg in it. The strawberry shortcakes ingredients were listed the same way but I knew their was no way the pound cake would be egg free. We settled on strawberry Jell-O with fruit on top. They basically ate the fruit off the top and wanted to go on to the Mr. Potato Head store.

Over all we were happy with the experience. The sandwiches were wrapped and bagged separately and we felt like our concerns were handled appropriately. Our first Disney dining experience with allergies: Success!

Recommend for Eggs, Peanuts, Tree Nuts, Soy Flour, and Soy Protein: Yes

If you would like to review Earl of Sandwich or any Disney restaurant, submit a food allergy dining Quick Review.

7 thoughts on “Earl of Sandwich with multiple food allergies – Downtown Disney”

  1. Earl of sandwich has assured me they do not fry anything in their restaurants. They state that their meatballs are oozed and held in the marinara sauce! Clearing things up. My pn/tn allergic daughter eats the pizza sandwich when ever we are in disney!

  2. We ate here with my 1.5 year old with peanut and tree nut allergies last year. Talked to manager about allergy friendly options and we were assured everything was fine. Cut to 20 mins later: hives, diarrhea, itching, Epipen and emergency room. Never again!

  3. Their mortadella contains tree nuts – so be careful that they don’t use the same knife to cut your sandwich, same surface, same gloves to prepare your sandwich, etc. if you have TN allergies.

    1. That’s an excellent point. We once had a bad experience at a local sandwich shop. After being extremely careful with ingredients, clean gloves, protected surface, etc., they used their standard knife to cut the sandwich in half, and it must have sliced dozens of other sandwiches with cheese.

  4. Shocked they use peanut oil. I'm not so sure about eating there now with our son who is pn/tn allergic. They never mentioned that to us. He always gets a turkey or ham, but still, I would like to know if they use anything for CC. That was never mentioned.

Comments are closed.